(Recipe adapted from this blogpost)
This post’s title is a big call, I know. But I HONESTLY thought that this was THE best cookie I have ever eaten (bought or made). Crisp on the outside with a chewy centre, oh so addictive, and damn easy to whip up in the TMX. I went to visit a friend and was tasked with ‘an accompaniment for coffee’ and decided to make a double recipe so I could bring some in to work. Boy, was I glad I did! I did add more chocolate than the recipe asked for, but as I hope you’ll agree, there’s no such thing as too much chocolate!
The original blogger’s hint to use chocolate chunks rather than chips is not something that should be ignored, one of the main reasons why this cookie was so addictive was how rewarded you felt when you bit into a large chunk of dark chocolate goodness!
Anyway, try this for yourself and let me know what you think.
125g soft brown sugar (important to use soft brown sugar rather than raw or any other variety as this contributes to the chewy texture)
125g butter (I never buy unsalted even if the recipe asks for it)
1 egg (the original blogpost has actually omitted this from the ingredient list for some reason, so I just guessed it would be one egg per recipe. Mine turned out ok in any case!)
175g plain flour
20g ground almond (I had ground hazelnuts handy so I used those)
1/4 tsp baking powder
1 tsp vanilla extract
20g ground almonds (I had ground hazelnuts handy so I used those)
100g chunky bits of dark, milk or white chocolate (as I mentioned I made a double recipe, so I used a 200g block of dark chocolate that I broke into pieces and then blitzed for a few seconds on speed 7. You get a combination of chunky bits but also very fine bits which I was initially a bit concerned about, but I think it ended up giving the cookies its rustic look. Then I found, oh, I don’t know, another 75g of chocolate in my pantry, so I dumped that in too. *evil laugh*)
– Place the butterfly whisk in the bowl and add the butter and soft brown sugar. Try not to do what I did and dump the butter on top of the butterfly, as you can see from my picture it wasn’t the smartest thing to do!
– Whisk for 3 min/speed 3, scraping down the mixture now and again. It should be creamy at this stage.
– Remove the whisk. Add the egg and mix for 30 sec/speed 3. Finish mixing with the spatula, turning clockwise to avoid the sharp end of the blades.
– Add the flour, ground nuts, baking powder and vanilla extract. Mix for 30 sec/speed 3 or until just combined. Don’t over-mix!
– Add the chocolate and mix for 15 sec/reverse/speed 2.
– Tip out onto cling film and roll into a sausage shape (about 6/7cm in diameter).
– Leave to set in the fridge for 1 hour (I left mine overnight).
– When you’re ready to bake, preheat the oven to 170 degrees Celcius.
– Cut your dough sausage into 1 or 2cm thick slices (thicker means a softer centre!) and place on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper. It doesn’t matter if these are shaped oddly, it adds to the charm.
– Leave to cool for a couple of minutes before lifting with a flat spatula and eat while still warm, although they’re still fab for a few days after.
– Try your best to offer them to someone else instead of wanting to inhale the whole tray. It’s hard, but you can do it.
If you’re in a cookie state of mind, you could also have a look at these recipes I’ve tried…
Jam drops (if someone gave you a jar of preserve and you don’t know what to do with it. Or, you know, if you like jam.)
Oatmeal and raisin (similar in texture to these bad boys!)
Peanut butter and chocolate chip cookies (one of the best combinations known to mankind)
Peanut cookies (may contain nuts)
Lime and coconut cookies (if you’re feeling tropical)